Fields neighboring the disciplines of kinesiology and sports science have called for more interdisciplinary work, including the adoption of critical approaches to research. This scoping review explored the degree to which critically-aligned research has developed within these disciplines. The goal was to identify who this research studied, what methods were used, and which theoretical and conceptual frameworks were adopted. Publications between 2010-2022 in six top kinesiology and sports science journals using four databases were searched using keywords to identify critically-aligned research. A multi-step screening process was used to identify and sort articles that adequately fit the criteria of critically-aligned research. The scoping review identified 5666 entries of which 3300 were unique publications. 76 articles were assessed to be critically-aligned. Four themes regarding demographics emerged: Geographic area, gender, race/ethnicity/indigeneity, and inequality/inequity. Regarding methodology, three major theoretical and conceptual frameworks emerged: ecological, socio-economic, and cultural. Overall, a relatively small number of studies fit our search criteria, suggesting that critically-aligned research remains at the margins of the disciplines. For the studies that were critically-aligned, they often centered the Global North and were inconsistent in their application of categories such as race, ethnicity, inequality and equity. These studies were diverse in their methodological approach while relying on ecological, socio-economic, and cultural frameworks. To heed the calls for a more interdisciplinary approach, and to advance the disciplines more generally, kinesiology and sports science should expand their adoption of critical approaches to research.
MULTIFILE
Een van die nieuwe ontwikkelingen van de Sport- en Beweegsector naar aanleiding van de veranderende maatschappij om ons heen is de start van de Master of Sports. Het is een feit dat de docent LO zijn grenzen namelijk steeds meer buiten de gymzaal verlegd. Voorbeelden hiervan zijn het functioneren als combinatie functionaris of leefstijladviseur, het organiseren van naschoolse sport en het participeren in stimulerings- en beweegprogramma's. Deze verbreding van het vak vereist professionalisering van het beroep. Onder professionalisering wordt onder andere verstaan het kunnen onderbouwen van keuzes. Bijvoorbeeld: wáárom wordt een bepaald beweegprogramma aangeboden, wanneer bepaal je of een programma effectief is en kun je dit meten? Kortom: wat is de maatschappelijke fundering van ons handelen? Het gaat verder dan 'gewoon doen wat je altijd doet en maar hopen dat het werkt'. Mogelijke antwoorden op deze vragen worden aangereikt tijdens de Master of Sports. Meer inhoudelijke en praktische informatie over de opleiding, evenals reacties van docenten en studenten kunt u terugvinden in dit themanummer 'Master of Sports. Professionalisering van de sport- en beweegsector'.
For twenty years, typical outdoor lifestyle sports like rafting, snowboarding and rock climbing, which used to be exclusively practised in natural environments, are being offered in controlled artificial settings. This process can be described as 'the indoorisation of outdoor sports'. With this development, questions of authenticity arise. Are these new, commercial forms still authentic lifestyle sports? And can we consider the participants in these indoorised lifestyle sports as authentic? There has been a discussion about authenticity in lifestyle sports since its worldwide popularisation and it is worth to reconsider this discussion against the background of new, commercial versions of lifestyle sports. Therefore, in this paper a qualitative analysis is offered about the consumption of a constructed authenticity in a cultural context increasingly characterized by artificialization.
